For More Free Videos, Subscribe to the Rhodes Brothers YouTube Channel.
“Most people who hold Bitcoin in the back of their mind think, ‘Well, I’m probably going to hold this forever. I never want to sell it.’ But that begs the question—what’s the point of owning Bitcoin if you’re never going to enjoy what it provides?”
— John S. Rhodes, Rhodes Brothers
Your portfolio just crossed a milestone—Bitcoin hit $250,000. The numbers look unreal. Years of conviction and patience are finally paying off. But now comes the hard part: what do you do next?
Do you sell and secure your gains? Hold on for more upside? Or freeze, unsure if taking action now means missing out later?
Here’s the truth: winning with Bitcoin isn’t about luck or guessing the top. It’s about having a smart, structured selling plan. Whether you’re a weekend dabbler or a long-time HODLer, a solid exit strategy helps you lock in profits, reduce emotional risk, and still stay in the game for the next big leg up.
This post is your comprehensive, step-by-step guide to building the perfect Bitcoin selling plan. We’re breaking down what John S. Rhodes calls the “never-sell-it-all” strategy, including:
- The 50% Rule to avoid regrets
- A practical reverse dollar-cost selling strategy
- Real-life price-point examples
- Tips for cashing out without losing your mind (or your fortune)
- Tools and techniques to profit smartly—even during market chaos
Whether you’re holding 0.1 BTC or 10 BTC, this is your roadmap to rational, rewarding, and regret-free selling.
TL;DR
- Don’t sell all your Bitcoin. Ever. Hold at least 50% for long-term upside.
- Sell in chunks as price increases—don’t try to time the very top.
- Use reverse dollar-cost averaging to sell smarter, not faster.
- Set sell points now, while you’re calm—not in the chaos of a bull run.
- Enjoy your gains with purpose: pay off debt, invest, or take that vacation.
- Avoid emotional decisions by sticking to a pre-set plan.
- Use tools like CoinTracking, Delta, or spreadsheets to track your sales.
- Remember: Volatility is your friend—if you plan ahead.
Why You Should Never Sell All Your Bitcoin
Selling Bitcoin might seem like the logical move when prices surge, but going all-in on cashing out can be one of the biggest mistakes you make as an investor. Why? Because Bitcoin is not just a speculative asset—it’s a long-term store of value with massive upside potential. By selling everything, you cut yourself off from the future gains that could come with the next wave of adoption, innovation, or economic shift. A smarter approach is keeping a portion of your holdings untouched, no matter what the market does.
The 50% Rule: A Simple, Powerful Framework
John S. Rhodes isn’t just talking theory—he’s walking the walk. His number one rule for selling Bitcoin?
“Never sell more than 50% of your stack—no matter what.”
Why? Because you never want to miss out on the next big move. Selling 100% in a panic or profit frenzy is what leads to crushing regret when Bitcoin breaks another all-time high.
Think of it like this:
- Half = your forever fund, stored in cold storage, never touched.
- The other half = your strategic sell-down stack.
This lets you enjoy life now without killing your future upside.
How to Sell Bitcoin Strategically (Without Losing Sleep)
Selling Bitcoin doesn’t have to be stressful, emotional, or reactive. In fact, with the right framework, it can be one of the most empowering parts of your investment journey. The key is to sell with intention, not impulse. Instead of trying to predict the perfect moment or waiting for media headlines to tell you what to do, you take control with a plan that’s tailored to your goals, timeline, and risk tolerance. One of the most effective and proven methods? Reverse dollar-cost averaging.
Reverse Dollar-Cost Selling: A Smarter Exit Plan
Instead of buying Bitcoin in small chunks over time (like dollar-cost averaging), we flip the method. This is called: Reverse Dollar-Cost Averaging
You sell small amounts at pre-determined price intervals.
Example Strategy
- Sell 0.1 BTC at $100,000
- Sell 0.1 BTC at $125,000
- Sell 0.1 BTC at $150,000
- Continue up to $500,000 or beyond
Benefits
- You lock in profits as Bitcoin rises
- Reduce emotional decision-making
- Spread your tax liability
- Stay invested for the long haul
As Albert Einstein once said: “A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new.”
In crypto, trying something new—like a structured selling plan—might be the smartest risk you take.
Tools to Help You Sell Smart
Here are some tools and platforms to support your Bitcoin selling plan
- CoinTracking: Tracks capital gains, losses, and portfolio performance
- Ledger Wallet: For storing your “never sell” BTC in cold storage
- Swan Bitcoin: A platform that allows you to automate buys and sells
- Google Sheets: Great for creating a custom sell plan with formulas and reminders
Actionable Steps for Different Investors
If you’re just getting started with Bitcoin, the first and most important step is deciding how much of your holdings you never plan to sell. A good rule of thumb is to commit to keeping at least 50% in long-term cold storage. From there, use a simple spreadsheet to outline your sell points—perhaps every $25,000 increase in Bitcoin’s price. This helps you create structure and avoid emotional decisions. To build confidence, practice selling small fractions so you become familiar with your exchange’s process.
For millennials focused on building wealth, your Bitcoin gains can be a powerful tool to fund major life goals. Whether it’s buying your first home, paying off student loans, or covering a wedding, strategic selling can turn digital profits into real-world progress. A reverse dollar-cost averaging plan—selling 10% at each significant price milestone—is a smart way to stay consistent. Consider reinvesting a portion of your profits into diversified, long-term assets like index funds or real estate to build a more balanced portfolio.
For those nearing retirement, the strategy shifts toward preservation and income. Selling small portions of Bitcoin as prices rise allows you to secure capital for retirement while still maintaining some exposure to future growth. The proceeds can be moved into more stable, income-generating investments such as bonds or dividend-paying stocks. It’s also wise to consult with a tax professional to ensure your withdrawals are optimized for your tax situation, helping you keep more of what you’ve earned.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Trying to time the top is one of the most tempting—but dangerous—mistakes Bitcoin investors make. The truth is, no one can consistently predict the market’s peak, not even seasoned pros. Bitcoin is notoriously volatile, and waiting for the “perfect” top often leads to missed opportunities or selling too late. Instead of aiming for perfection, focus on consistency. Selling in pre-planned increments as the price rises ensures you lock in profits without the stress of hitting the exact high point.
Selling all at once is another emotionally charged decision that usually stems from fear or euphoria. Whether it’s panic during a dip or excitement during a parabolic run-up, liquidating your entire position in one move rarely ends well. If Bitcoin continues to rise after you’ve sold everything, regret sets in fast. Gradual selling not only reduces emotional risk—it also allows you to benefit from continued growth while still enjoying gains along the way.
Not having a plan leaves you vulnerable to market swings and emotional reactions. Without a clear sell strategy, you’re more likely to make impulsive decisions based on headlines, social media hype, or short-term noise. A structured plan brings clarity, purpose, and confidence. Knowing exactly how much you’ll sell and when gives you peace of mind, especially in moments of extreme volatility.
Ignoring taxes can be a costly oversight. Many investors forget that every sale of Bitcoin is a taxable event. Depending on where you live, capital gains taxes can take a significant chunk out of your profits—especially if you’ve held your assets for less than a year. Failing to plan for taxes can result in unexpected bills or even penalties. It’s wise to track your transactions, understand local tax laws, and work with a CPA or crypto tax software to stay compliant and optimize your liability.
Selling for the wrong reasons—like peer pressure, social media hype, or fear of missing out—can derail your long-term goals. Selling should be a strategic decision tied to your personal financial objectives, not a reaction to external noise. Ask yourself: is this sale helping me achieve something meaningful, like buying a home, funding retirement, or reducing debt? If not, pause. Align your selling decisions with your life goals, not the latest trend on Twitter.
By avoiding these common pitfalls, you’ll not only protect your capital—you’ll also strengthen your ability to make smart, rational decisions that support your financial future.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I get started with a Bitcoin selling plan?
Start by deciding what percentage you’ll never sell. Then create a list of price points where you’ll sell small portions of the rest.
What’s the best percentage to sell at each level?
Many investors sell 10% of their sellable stack at each milestone, but it depends on your goals.
Can I sell Bitcoin in pieces?
Yes. Bitcoin is divisible up to 8 decimal places. You can sell as little as 0.0001 BTC.
What if Bitcoin crashes before I sell?
That’s why selling incrementally on the way up is key—you’ll have already taken some profits.
Where should I store my “never sell” BTC?
Use a cold storage wallet like Ledger or Trezor. Never store large amounts on exchanges.
What are capital gains taxes on Bitcoin?
This varies by country. In the U.S., long-term gains (over 1 year) are taxed at a lower rate than short-term.
Should I sell my ETF (like GBTC) the same way?
Yes. Set sell rules based on Bitcoin’s price or the ETF’s value.
Is volatility a bad thing?
Not if planned for. Volatility creates opportunity. The key is to prepare for it with a plan.
Should I reinvest my profits?
Yes, if it aligns with your goals. Consider index funds, dividend stocks, or real estate.
What if I want to use Bitcoin for income later?
Eventually, banks or brokerages may offer yield on BTC. Until then, strategic selling is your best option.
Your Financial Freedom Game Plan Starts Now
You’ve just learned how to sell Bitcoin smartly—without panic, without regret, and with a plan that honors both your current needs and your future dreams.
Here’s your quick start guide:
- Decide what percent to hold forever
- Set your sell increments and price points
- Track your sales and profits
- Use profits intentionally—to live, invest, or give
- Avoid emotional decisions during spikes or dips
“Do this before it’s too late.” — John S. Rhodes
Start your selling plan today. Your future self will thank you.
Thanks for joining us on this journey. For even more insights, strategies, and personal finance tips, check out and subscribe to the Rhodes Brothers YouTube Channel.
Resource List
Books
- The Bitcoin Standard by Saifedean Ammous
- Cryptoassets by Chris Burniske
- The Psychology of Money by Morgan Housel
Podcasts
Tools
- CoinTracking – for tax and portfolio tracking
- Swan Bitcoin – automate recurring buys and sells
- Ledger Wallet – secure cold storage
- Google Sheets – for creating custom sell-down plans
Courses & Learning
- Bitcoin & Cryptocurrency Technologies – Coursera
- Cryptocurrency Investment Course 2024 – Udemy
- Blockchain and Money – MIT OpenCourseWare
Communities & Blogs
